# 5 Best Ways to Check if a Final String Can Be Formed Using Two Other Strings in Python

Rate this post

π‘ Problem Formulation: Imagine you are given three strings: `str1`, `str2`, and `str3`. Your task is to determine if `str3` can be formed by using characters from `str1` and `str2`, in any order, without rearranging the characters within `str1` and `str2`. For instance, if `str1 = "abc"`, `str2 = "def"`, and `str3 = "dabecf"`, the program should return `True` as `str3` can be formed from the interleaving of the characters from `str1` and `str2`.

## Method 1: Using Recursion

This method employs a recursive function to check all possible interleave combinations to see if they can form the final string. The function explores each possible interleaving path using a depth-first approach. It is suitable for smaller strings as its time complexity increases exponentially with the length of the strings.

Here’s an example:

```def is_interleave(str1, str2, str3):
if not str1 and not str2 and not str3:
return True
if len(str3) != len(str1) + len(str2):
return False
if str1 and str3[0] == str1[0] and is_interleave(str1[1:], str2, str3[1:]):
return True
if str2 and str3[0] == str2[0] and is_interleave(str1, str2[1:], str3[1:]):
return True
return False

print(is_interleave("abc", "def", "dabecf"))```

Output: `True`

This code defines a function `is_interleave()` that checks if `str3` is an interleaving of `str1` and `str2`. It does so by recursively checking if the first character of `str3` matches with the first character of either `str1` or `str2` and continues this process. The base case checks for the empty string condition or length mismatch, which invalidate the interleaving.

## Method 2: Dynamic Programming

This method improves upon the first by using dynamic programming to store intermediate results, thus avoiding repeated calculations and significantly reducing the time complexity. A 2D table is created to track whether substrings of `str1` and `str2` can form substrings of `str3`.

Here’s an example:

```def is_interleave_dp(str1, str2, str3):
if len(str3) != len(str1) + len(str2):
return False
dp = [[False] * (len(str2) + 1) for _ in range(len(str1) + 1)]
dp[0][0] = True
for i in range(1, len(str1) + 1):
dp[i][0] = dp[i-1][0] and str1[i-1] == str3[i-1]
for j in range(1, len(str2) + 1):
dp[0][j] = dp[0][j-1] and str2[j-1] == str3[j-1]
for i in range(1, len(str1) + 1):
for j in range(1, len(str2) + 1):
dp[i][j] = (dp[i-1][j] and str1[i-1] == str3[i+j-1]) or (dp[i][j-1] and str2[j-1] == str3[i+j-1])
return dp[-1][-1]

print(is_interleave_dp("abc", "def", "dabecf"))```

Output: `True`

This snippet showcases a dynamic programming approach within the `is_interleave_dp()` function. It initializes a table `dp` to store boolean values, where `dp[i][j]` indicates whether or not a substring of `str3` up to length `i + j` can be formed by interleaving substrings of `str1` up to length `i` and `str2` up to length `j`.

## Method 3: Using itertools

The itertools library has a powerful function named `product()` which can compute the Cartesian product of given iterables. By applying this to subsets of `str1` and `str2`, we can generate all possible interleavings and then check if `str3` matches any of them. This approach can be computationally intensive for longer strings.

Here’s an example:

```from itertools import product

def is_interleave_itertools(str1, str2, str3):
for combo in product(*zip(str1, str2)):
if ''.join(combo) == str3:
return True
return False

print(is_interleave_itertools("abc", "def", "dabecf"))```

Output: `True`

In this code, we import `product()` from itertools and use it to pair characters from `str1` with `str2`. For each combination, we join the characters and check if it matches `str3`. The `is_interleave_itertools()` function returns True if a match is found.

## Method 4: Greedy Algorithm

The greedy method processes the characters of `str3` and attempts to match them with characters from `str1` and `str2` in a greedy manner. It always takes the match that appears first. While not always correct for all possible inputs, it is very efficient for certain patterns and could be considered as an optimization under some specific constraints.

Here’s an example:

```def is_interleave_greedy(str1, str2, str3):
i = j = 0
for c in str3:
if i < len(str1) and c == str1[i]:
i += 1
elif j < len(str2) and c == str2[j]:
j += 1
else:
return False
return i == len(str1) and j == len(str2)

print(is_interleave_greedy("abc", "def", "dabecf"))```

Output: `True`

The function `is_interleave_greedy()` iterates through each character in `str3` and checks if it can be found in order in either `str1` or `str2`. It increases counters `i` and `j` for each string respectively, and verifies that all characters were used exactly once in the end.

## Bonus One-Liner Method 5: Using Python Sets

This concise method uses Python’s set operations to determine if the sorted set of characters in `str3` is the same as the union of the sorted sets of `str1` and `str2`. This method doesn’t check for the order of letters but can work as a quick preliminary check.

Here’s an example:

```is_interleave_set = lambda str1, str2, str3: set(str1) | set(str2) == set(str3) and len(str1) + len(str2) == len(str3)

print(is_interleave_set("abc", "def", "dabecf"))```

Output: `True`

The one-liner uses a lambda function to check if the union of the sets of `str1` and `str2` equals the set of `str3`, coupled with a length check to ensure all characters are accounted for. This method doesn’t validate the interleaving sequence but rather the presence of characters.

## Summary/Discussion

• Method 1: Recursion. Good for small strings due to simplicity. Not efficient for longer strings due to its exponential time complexity.
• Method 2: Dynamic Programming. Efficient in both time and space for larger strings. It can be complicated to implement and understand.
• Method 3: itertools. Simple to implement but not efficient for long strings due to generating all combinations.
• Method 4: Greedy Algorithm. Fast and simple but may not work correctly on all possible inputs, especially on strings with repeated characters.
• Method 5: Python Sets. A quick check that doesn’t account for order but confirms character composition and total length.