5 Best Ways to Check Whether Two Pandas Interval Objects Overlap

by

💡 Problem Formulation: In data analysis using Python’s Pandas library, it’s common to work with intervals or periods representing ranges of data. At times, we need to determine if two such interval objects have any overlap, which can be crucial for temporal data analysis, scheduling, and time series. For example, given two interval objects, Interval(1, 3) and Interval(2, 4), the desired output is a boolean value indicating that these intervals do indeed overlap.

Method 1: Using the Interval.overlaps() Method

This method provides a straightforward way to check for overlapping intervals by utilizing the built-in overlaps() function in the Pandas Interval object. The function returns True when two intervals share common points that are not merely endpoint-exclusive, otherwise, it returns False.

Here’s an example:

import pandas as pd

interval1 = pd.Interval(1, 3, closed='right')
interval2 = pd.Interval(2, 4, closed='right')
result = interval1.overlaps(interval2)
print(result)

Output: True

We created two interval objects with right-closed boundaries and used overlaps() to determine if there’s an overlap between them. The function correctly identifies that intervals (1, 3] and (2, 4] do overlap, hence it returns True.

Method 2: Comparing Interval Boundaries

One can manually check for overlaps by comparing the start and end boundaries of each interval. Overlap is confirmed if the start of one interval is less than the end of the other interval and vice versa.

Here’s an example:

interval1_start = 1
interval1_end = 3
interval2_start = 2
interval2_end = 4

result = (interval1_start < interval2_end) and (interval2_start < interval1_end)
print(result)

Output: True

In this snippet, we handled four variables representing the ends of two intervals and compared them manually. The logic is that if interval A starts before interval B ends and B starts before A ends, they overlap. The result, as expected, is True.

Method 3: Using the IntervalIndex Object

The IntervalIndex object in Pandas allows for the manipulation and analysis of multiple intervals as a collection. Checking for overlap can be done more systematically when handling many intervals.

Here’s an example:

import pandas as pd

intervals = pd.IntervalIndex.from_tuples([(1, 3), (2, 4)])
result = intervals.overlaps(pd.Interval(1.5, 2.5))
print(result)

Output: True

This approach deals with a collection of intervals. We create an IntervalIndex from a list of tuples representing interval ranges, then check if a specified interval overlaps with any intervals within the collection. The printed result confirms the expected overlap.

Method 4: Using Set Intersection

The notion of overlap can be translated to the concept of set intersection in mathematics. By converting intervals to sets of discrete points, we can determine an overlap by the non-emptiness of the intersection of these sets.

Here’s an example:

interval1 = set(range(1, 4))
interval2 = set(range(2, 5))

result = bool(interval1.intersection(interval2))
print(result)

Output: True

This code uses the range() function to represent each interval as a set of discrete integers, then checks the intersection between them to test for overlap. Since the intersection is non-empty, it returns True, indicating an overlap.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: Using Logical AND on Overlap Condition

A compact way to check for overlap is by using a one-liner boolean expression that encapsulates the boundary comparison logic into a single line.

Here’s an example:

result = (min(3, 4) > max(1, 2))
print(result)

Output: True

The snippet employs a minimalistic approach, compressing the overlap logic into the comparison of the minimum of the end boundaries and the maximum of the start boundaries. This approach is elegant and works well for simple cases.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: Using Interval.overlaps(). Straightforward and built into Pandas. Limits to checking pairwise.
  • Method 2: Comparing Boundaries. Simple logic, does not rely on Pandas. May become verbose with more complex interval checks.
  • Method 3: Using IntervalIndex. Ideal for collections of intervals. Requires understanding of Pandas’ advanced indexing capabilities.
  • Method 4: Set Intersection. Intuitive to those familiar with set theory. Not suitable for intervals with non-discrete points or very large ranges.
  • Method 5: Logical AND on Condition. Quick one-liner. Lacks the clarity and readability of long-form code for complex conditions.