5 Best Ways to Compute Element Wise Arc Tangent of x1 and x2 Choosing the Quadrant Correctly in Python

by

💡 Problem Formulation: Computing the element-wise arc tangent of two arrays, X1 and X2, involves determining the angle theta such that tan(theta) = X2/X1, while taking into account the correct quadrant of the angle based on the signs of X1 and X2. The desired output is an array of angles in radians, ranging from -π to π. For example, given X1 = [1, -1] and X2 = [1, 1], the correct quadrant-aware result should be [π/4, 3π/4].

Method 1: Using NumPy’s arctan2() Function

NumPy library has a function arctan2() that calculates the arc tangent of the quotient of two arrays element-wise. It returns the angles in radians and considers the quadrant of the inputs, making it a robust choice for this problem. numpy.arctan2(x1, x2) needs two arrays of the same shape as input and returns the angles, considering the signs of both inputs to determine the correct quadrant.

Here’s an example:

import numpy as np

x1 = np.array([1, -1])
x2 = np.array([1, 1])
angles = np.arctan2(x2, x1)

print(angles)

Output of this code snippet:

[ 0.78539816  2.35619449]

This code snippet demonstrates the use of the np.arctan2() function from the NumPy library to compute the correct quadrant-wise arc tangent values for the given arrays X1 and X2. The printout shows the angles in radians, resulting in π/4 and 3π/4 respectively, corresponding to the correct quadrants for the input values.

Method 2: Using Math Library’s atan2() Function

The math library in Python also provides an atan2() function that computes the arc tangent of two numbers. Unlike NumPy, it handles numerical inputs rather than arrays, but it can be used in a loop or with list comprehension to achieve the same element-wise behavior. It correctly handles the signs of the arguments to compute the arc tangent in the correct quadrant.

Here’s an example:

import math

x1 = [1, -1]
x2 = [1, 1]
angles = [math.atan2(y, x) for x, y in zip(x1, x2)]

print(angles)

Output of this code snippet:

[0.7853981633974483, 2.356194490192345]

In this code example, we use list comprehension to apply the math.atan2() function to each pair of elements drawn from X1 and X2. The output is the same as the previous method: an array of angles in radians that correctly reflects the quadrants of the input coordinates.

Method 3: Using a Custom Function with Element-wise Operations

For a more hands-on approach, one can define a custom function that manually checks the signs of X1 and X2 elements and uses the math.atan() function to compute the arc tangent, adjusted for the correct quadrant. This method requires additional logic but is good for deep understanding.

Here’s an example:

import math

def custom_arctan2(y, x):
    angle = math.atan(abs(y)/abs(x))
    if x >= 0 and y >= 0:
        return angle
    elif x = 0:
        return math.pi - angle
    elif x < 0 and y < 0:
        return -math.pi + angle
    else:
        return -angle

x1 = [1, -1]
x2 = [1, 1]
angles = [custom_arctan2(y, x) for x, y in zip(x1, x2)]

print(angles)

Output of this code snippet:

[0.7853981633974483, 2.356194490192345]

This code snippet introduces a custom function, custom_arctan2(), that calculates the arc tangent while considering the quadrant manually. The function adjusts the angle depending on the signs of X and Y. When used in combination with list comprehension, it generates the correct quadrant-aware angles for the pairs of X1 and X2.

Method 4: Using SymPy’s atan2() Function

SymPy is a Python library for symbolic mathematics. It includes an atan2() function that can operate element-wise on symbolic objects or numerical values. SymPy’s atan2() carefully respects mathematical rigor, which can be beneficial for applications needing symbolic computation capabilities.

Here’s an example:

from sympy import atan2

x1 = [1, -1]
x2 = [1, 1]
angles = [atan2(y, x) for x, y in zip(x1, x2)]

print(angles)

Output of this code snippet:

[pi/4, 3*pi/4]

This example utilizes SymPy’s atan2() function within a list comprehension to compute the quadrant-aware arc tangent of each pair of elements from the lists X1 and X2. SymPy returns the result as symbolic expressions which are useful for further symbolic manipulations.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: Using NumPy with Lambda and Map

For a quick one-liner, NumPy’s arctan2() function can be coupled with the lambda function and map() to apply the operation in an element-wise manner. This approach is concise but might lack clarity for those unfamiliar with lambda functions.

Here’s an example:

import numpy as np

x1 = [1, -1]
x2 = [1, 1]
angles = list(map(lambda pair: np.arctan2(pair[1], pair[0]), zip(x1, x2)))

print(angles)

Output of this code snippet:

[0.7853981633974483, 2.356194490192345]

This snippet succinctly demonstrates combining the use of a lambda function with map() to calculate the angles using NumPy’s arctan2(). The zip function pairs up elements from X1 and X2, which are then processed by lambda to give us the desired result.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: NumPy’s arctan2() function. Strengths: Vectorized operations, performance, and simplicity. Weaknesses: Dependency on an external library.
  • Method 2: Math library’s atan2(). Strengths: Part of the standard library, no additional installation required. Weaknesses: Not designed for element-wise array operations, less performance-efficient.
  • Method 3: Custom Function. Strengths: Deep understanding of the quadrant adjustment process. Weaknesses: Verbose and prone to human error.
  • Method 4: SymPy’s atan2(). Strengths: Provides symbolic results, which is useful for certain types of mathematical problems. Weaknesses: Overhead of symbolic computation, not as performance-efficient as numerical methods.
  • Method 5: NumPy with Lambda and Map. Strengths: Concise and functional-programming style. Weaknesses: May be less readable for those not familiar with lambda and map functions.