5 Best Ways to Detect Rectangle Overlap in Python

by

💡 Problem Formulation: This article explores different methods to determine whether two rectangles in a 2D space overlap. Rectangles are defined by their top-left and bottom-right coordinates, for instance, rectangle A might be given as ((Ax1, Ay1), (Ax2, Ay2)) and rectangle B as ((Bx1, By1), (Bx2, By2)). The desired output is a boolean indicating whether there is an overlap.

Method 1: Calculating Overlap Area

This method involves calculating the area of overlap between two rectangles. It checks if there are any non-overlapping cases first, and if none, then the rectangles must overlap. The specification is to return True if the rectangles overlap, otherwise False.

Here’s an example:

def is_overlap(rect1, rect2):
    left = max(rect1[0][0], rect2[0][0])
    right = min(rect1[1][0], rect2[1][0])
    top = max(rect1[0][1], rect2[0][1])
    bottom = min(rect1[1][1], rect2[1][1])
    
    if left < right and top < bottom:
        return True
    return False

# Test the function
rectA = ((1, 4), (6, 1))
rectB = ((5, 5), (8, 2))

print(is_overlap(rectA, rectB))

Output: True

This code snippet first identifies the potential overlapping region by calculating the extremes of the intersection (if any exists). It then checks if the computed coordinates form a legitimate region by ensuring that the top and bottom as well as left and right form an intersecting rectangle.

Method 2: Separating Axis Theorem

The Separating Axis Theorem (SAT) states that two convex shapes do not overlap if you can find a line (axis) on which the projections of the shapes do not overlap. When applied to rectangles, this translates to comparing the x and y ranges for overlap.

Here’s an example:

def is_separated(rect1, rect2):
    if rect1[1][0] < rect2[0][0] or rect2[1][0] < rect1[0][0]:
        return True
    if rect1[1][1] < rect2[0][1] or rect2[1][1] < rect1[0][1]:
        return True
    return False

# Test the function
print(is_separated(rectA, rectB))

Output: False

This code applies the SAT by checking if there’s a separation on the x-axis or y-axis—indicative of no overlap. If neither condition is True, then there is an overlap between the rectangles.

Method 3: Comparing Edges

By comparing the edges of the rectangles, we can determine if one rectangle is to the left, right, above, or below the other. If none of these conditions is true, the rectangles overlap.

Here’s an example:

def does_not_overlap(rect1, rect2):
    if (rect1[1][0] <= rect2[0][0] or rect2[1][0] <= rect1[0][0] or
        rect1[1][1] <= rect2[0][1] or rect2[1][1] <= rect1[0][1]):
        return True
    return False

# Test the function
print(does_not_overlap(rectA, rectB))

Output: False

Similar to SAT, this approach checks whether one rectangle is completely to the left, right, above, or below the other. If none of these cases is true, then an overlap is implied.

Method 4: Using Geometry Libraries

Python has geometry libraries such as Shapely that provide sophisticated spatial analysis functions. One can use the intersection method provided by the library to detect an overlap between polygon shapes representing the rectangles.

Here’s an example:

from shapely.geometry import Polygon

def is_overlap_shapely(rect1, rect2):
    poly1 = Polygon([rect1[0], (rect1[0][0], rect1[1][1]), rect1[1], (rect1[1][0], rect1[0][1])])
    poly2 = Polygon([rect2[0], (rect2[0][0], rect2[1][1]), rect2[1], (rect2[1][0], rect2[0][1])])
    
    return poly1.intersects(poly2)

# Test the function
print(is_overlap_shapely(rectA, rectB))

Output: True

This snippet uses the Shapely library to create Polygon objects representing the rectangles and then calls the intersects method to check for overlap, which makes the process straightforward and handles more complex shapes if needed.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: Using Python Lambda

If you crave a more Pythonic one-liner, this method uses a lambda function encapsulating the logic to compute whether overlap exists, based on coordinate comparisons.

Here’s an example:

is_overlap_oneliner = lambda r1, r2: not (r1[1][0] < r2[0][0] or r2[1][0] < r1[0][0] or r1[1][1] < r2[0][1] or r2[1][1] < r1[0][1])
print(is_overlap_oneliner(rectA, rectB))

Output: True

Using a lambda function along with a logical statement, this example matches the comparing edges method in a single line, providing an elegant and concise way to solve the issue.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: Calculating Overlap Area. Straightforward and easy to understand. Can be less efficient due to multiple comparisons and calculations.
  • Method 2: Separating Axis Theorem. More mathematical approach, efficient for axis-aligned rectangles. Not as intuitive for beginners.
  • Method 3: Comparing Edges. Simple and direct. Can quickly become inefficient as the complexity of the shapes increases.
  • Method 4: Using Geometry Libraries. Leverages advanced library features for a robust solution. Requires external dependencies, which may be overkill for simple tasks.
  • Bonus Method 5: Using Python Lambda. Offers concise code for small scripts. Might reduce readability for those unfamiliar with lambda functions.