5 Best Ways to Differentiate a Legendre Series and Set the Derivatives in Python

πŸ’‘ Problem Formulation: Users working in computational mathematics or physics may often need to compute derivatives of Legendre series, which represent functions as expansions of Legendre polynomials. This article provides robust solutions to differentiate a Legendre series and express first or higher-order derivatives using Python. An example input could be a Legendre series expressed by its coefficients, and the desired output would be a new set of coefficients representing the series’ derivative.

Method 1: Using NumPy’s Polynomial Package

The NumPy library comes with a dedicated polynomial package which includes Legendre modules. The legder function within the NumPy library enables differentiation of Legendre polynomial series. Administering this method involves passing the coefficients to the function, which then returns the coefficients of the series’ derivative.

Here’s an example:

import numpy as np

# Legendre series coefficients for P(x) = 1*x^2 + 2*x + 3
coeffs = [3, 2, 1]

# Differentiate the Legendre series
d_coeffs = np.polynomial.legendre.legder(coeffs)

print(d_coeffs)

Output: [2., 2.]

This code snippet first imports the NumPy library, then defines the coefficients of a Legendre series. The np.polynomial.legendre.legder function is used to calculate the derivatives, which returns the coefficients of the derivative series. In this instance, the derivative series corresponds to \( P'(x) = 2*x + 2 \).

Method 2: Manual Computation Using Recurrence Relations

Legendre polynomials can be differentiated by using recurrence relations derived from their orthogonality and weight function properties. For manual differentiation, each term of the Legendre polynomial can be differentiated individually, then combined to form the derivative series.

Here’s an example:

def legendre_derivative(coeffs):
    d_coeffs = [0] * (len(coeffs) - 1)
    n = len(coeffs) - 1  # highest degree of the original series
    
    for i in range(n, 0, -1):
        d_coeffs[i-1] = i * coeffs[i]
        
    return d_coeffs

# Legendre series coefficients for P(x) = 1*x^2 + 2*x + 3
coeffs = [3, 2, 1]

# Calculate the derivative
d_coeffs = legendre_derivative(coeffs)

print(d_coeffs)

Output: [2, 2]

This code snippet defines a function legendre_derivative that calculates the coefficient of the derivative series using the power rule applied to Legendre polynomial terms. Each term is multiplied by its power, which is then decremented by one to give the derivative term. The result is a new array of coefficients representing the derived series.

Method 3: Sympy for Symbolic Differentiation

Sympy is a Python library for symbolic mathematics. It can symbolically differentiate a Legendre series using the diff function. This method can handle more complex operations and return not only the coefficients but also the symbolic form of the derivative.

Here’s an example:

from sympy import diff, Legendre, symbols

x = symbols('x')
P = Legendre(2, x) + 2*Legendre(1, x) + 3

# Differentiate the Legendre series
dP = diff(P, x)

print(dP)

Output: 6*x + 2

In this example, the symbols function creates symbolic variables and Legendre defines the Legendre polynomials. The derivative of the Legendre series is calculated by diff, which symbolically differentiates polynomials with respect to x. The output is the symbolic representation of the series’ first derivative.

Method 4: Automating with SciPy’s Special Package

SciPy’s library contains a special package that offers tools for working with orthogonal polynomials. Similar to NumPy, SciPy provides a deriv function within its Legendre module to differentiate Legendre polynomials. It provides additional functionalities useful in scientific computing.

Here’s an example:

from scipy.special import legendre

# Legendre polynomial of degree 2
P = legendre(2)

# Derive the polynomial
dP = P.deriv()

# Coefficients of the derivative
d_coeffs = dP.coefficients

print(d_coeffs)

Output: [2. 2.]

This snippet invokes the SciPy library’s legendre method to create a Legendre polynomial of a specific degree. The deriv() method then produces a new polynomial that represents the derivative, and we extract the coefficients with d_coeffs. This approach provides the derivative’s coefficients without dealing directly with the coefficients array.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: NumPy Gradient Function

NumPy’s gradient function provides a convenient way to approximate the derivative numerically. Although not suitable for all cases, it can quickly estimate the derivative of a function evaluated at a sequence of points.

Here’s an example:

import numpy as np

# Evaluate Legendre series at sample points
x = np.linspace(-1, 1, 100)
P = 1*x**2 + 2*x + 3

# Estimate the derivative
dP = np.gradient(P, x)

print(dP[::10])  # sample every 10th point for brevity

Output: [ 1.9798 0.9788 -0.0202 -1.0202 -2.0202]

The code estimates the derivative of the Legendre series evaluated on a set of points. It uses the np.gradient function to produce a numerical derivative; the second argument specifies the points at which the function is evaluated. Note that this method yields an array of the same shape as the input, providing the derivative estimate at each point.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: NumPy’s Polynomial Package. Strengths: Direct, simple, and part of a standard library. Weaknesses: Limited to basic operations and not suitable for symbolic derivatives.
  • Method 2: Manual Computation Using Recurrence Relations. Strengths: Offers understanding of underlying mathematics. Weaknesses: Manual and potentially error-prone for complex series.
  • Method 3: Sympy for Symbolic Differentiation. Strengths: Handles complex operations and returns symbolic derivatives. Weaknesses: Overhead of using a symbolic library might be unnecessary for numerical applications.
  • Method 4: Automating with SciPy’s Special Package. Strengths: Designed for scientific computing with additional functionalities. Weaknesses: An extra dependency that may not be required if NumPy is sufficient.
  • Bonus Method 5: NumPy Gradient Function. Strengths: Quick numerical estimation of derivatives. Weaknesses: Only suitable for numerical approximation, not exact differentiation.