5 Best Ways to Differentiate a Legendre Series with Multidimensional Coefficients Over Axis 1 in Python

by

💡 Problem Formulation: Differentiating a mathematical series can be an essential part of scientific computing, particularly when it involves Legendre polynomials used in various fields such as physics and engineering. Handling series data with multidimensional coefficients introduces a complexity that is often addressed in Python. For a given multidimensional array representing Legendre coefficients, we aim to compute the derivative over a specified axis—axis 1 in this case—to analyze or transform the series further. Imagine an input as a 3D array where each ‘layer’ corresponds to a set of Legendre coefficients, and the desired output is a similar 3D array with each layer differentiated over the second dimension.

Method 1: Using NumPy’s Gradient Function

NumPy’s np.gradient() function calculates the numerical gradient of an array, which can approximate differentiation. By specifying the axis parameter, we can differentiate along axis 1. This method is excellent for quick and approximate differentiation on uniformly spaced points and is built into the widely-used NumPy library, making it accessible.

Here’s an example:

import numpy as np

# Let f be an array with Legendre series coefficients 
# with 3 dimensions: the second one being the one we differentiate over
f = np.random.rand(5, 10, 5) # replace with actual coefficients
df = np.gradient(f, axis=1)

print(df.shape)

Output: (5, 10, 5)

We initialize a 3D array f to simulate the Legendre coefficients array. The np.gradient() function computes the gradient along axis 1. The output confirms that the resulting array maintains the original shape while differentiating along the specified axis.

Method 2: SymPy for Symbolic Differentiation

SymPy is a Python library for symbolic mathematics that can perform exact differentiation. It’s well-suited for situations where precision is necessary, as it computes the derivative symbolically rather than numerically. SymPy can handle polynomials, including Legendre series, and thus can be used for differentiating them with respect to specific variables or axes.

Here’s an example:

import sympy as sp
import numpy as np

x = sp.Symbol('x')
# Define a Legendre series as a SymPy expression
P = sp.legendre(3, x)  # Third degree Legendre polynomial
dP = sp.diff(P, x)  # Differentiate

# Evaluate the derivative at a set of points, for example 10 points along axis 1
axis_1_points = np.linspace(-1, 1, 10)
dP_at_points = [float(dP.subs(x, xi)) for xi in axis_1_points]

print(dP_at_points)

Output: The evaluated derivative at specified points on axis 1

This code snippet uses SymPy to define a Legendre polynomial of degree 3 and then differentiates it with respect to x. The derivative is then evaluated at 10 points along axis 1. This method ensures an exact computation, useful for theoretical analyses or when working with symbolic data.

Method 3: Using SciPy’s Special Package

SciPy, an open-source Python library for scientific computing, has a ‘special’ package containing functions for working with orthogonal polynomials, including Legendre polynomials. SciPy’s differentiation functions allow precise numerical differentiation, and are more specialized than NumPy’s gradient function, making them suitable for Legendre series with multidimensional coefficients.

Here’s an example:

from scipy.special import legendre
from scipy.misc import derivative
import numpy as np

# Let's assume we already have the Legendre polynomial function
f = legendre(3)  # Third degree Legendre polynomial
# Define the points along axis 1 for differentiation
x = np.linspace(-1, 1, 10)

# Differentiate along axis 1
df_dx = np.array([derivative(f, xk, dx=1e-6) for xk in x])

print(df_dx.shape)

Output: (10,)

In this code snippet, we have used SciPy’s legendre() function to define a Legendre polynomial of degree 3 and derivative() function to differentiate it numerically. The differentiation is performed at a series of points along axis 1, representing the multidimensional coefficients being differentiated.

Method 4: Using Autograd

Autograd is a Python library that can automatically differentiate native Python and NumPy code. It can handle a large variety of mathematical operations, making it ideal for differentiating complex Legendre series with multidimensional coefficients. Unlike numerical differentiation, Autograd differentiates at machine precision.

Here’s an example:

import autograd.numpy as np
from autograd import grad

# Define a function for computing the Legendre polynomial value
def legendre_series(x, coeff):
    return np.polynomial.legendre.legval(x, coeff)

coefficients = np.random.rand(10)  # Coefficients of the Legendre series
d_legendre_series = grad(legendre_series, 0)  # Get the gradient function

# Evaluate the derivative with respect to the first argument (x)
d_coefficients = d_legendre_series(0.5, coefficients)

print(d_coefficients)

Output: Value of the derivative at x = 0.5

The code uses Autograd’s version of NumPy to define a function for evaluating Legendre polynomials and then computes its derivative using grad(). This method computes the derivative to a specified point but can be extended to differentiate over an entire axis by evaluating it at multiple points.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: NumPy Polynomial Library

NumPy’s polynomial library includes a convenient method numpy.polynomial.legendre.Legendre.deriv() that returns a new Legendre series instance representing the derivative. This is by far the simplest and easiest method when working with Legendre polynomials and their coefficients in a purely numerical setting.

Here’s an example:

from numpy.polynomial.legendre import Legendre

# Define example Legendre coefficients. In practice, replace with actual coefficients.
coeffs = [1, 2, 3]
# Create a Legendre series object
L = Legendre(coeffs)
# Compute the derivative of the series
L_deriv = L.deriv()

print(L_deriv)

Output: Legendre series object representing the derivative

This code snippet creates a Legendre series object with specified coefficients and calls the deriv() method to compute its derivative, providing a simple, effective way to differentiate Legendre polynomials.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: NumPy’s Gradient Function. Quick and easily accessible approximation for numerical differentiation. Does not provide exact results and practical for uniformly spaced points.
  • Method 2: SymPy for Symbolic Differentiation. Provides exact differentiation for symbolic computations, but may be slower and not suitable for large-scale or purely numerical data.
  • Method 3: Using SciPy’s Special Package. Offers specialized functions for numerical differentiation of Legendre polynomials. More precise than NumPy, but still inherently approximate.
  • Method 4: Using Autograd. Enables machine-precision automatic differentiation of Python code, offering precise numerical results. However, it may require familiarity with the Autograd library and its conventions.
  • Bonus Method 5: NumPy Polynomial Library. Simplest numerical method using NumPy’s polynomial library, ideal for straightforward differentiation tasks with Legendre polynomials.