Finding Common Columns Between Two DataFrames in Pandas

by

💡 Problem Formulation: In data analysis with Python’s Pandas library, a common task is comparing the columns of two DataFrames to find which columns are present in both. Users may want to perform this operation to align datasets for merging, analysis or consistency checks. For example, given two DataFrames with some overlapping and non-overlapping column names, the desired output is a list of column names that exist in both DataFrames.

Method 1: Using Sets to Identify Common Columns

Using sets in Python, we can easily find the intersection of the columns of two DataFrames. The set data structure provides an efficient way to perform this task as it is designed specifically for operations like intersections, unions, and differences. The intersection() method or the & operator on sets can be used to obtain the common elements.

Here’s an example:

import pandas as pd

# Create sample DataFrames
df1 = pd.DataFrame(columns=['A', 'B', 'C'])
df2 = pd.DataFrame(columns=['B', 'C', 'D'])

# Find common columns
common_columns = set(df1.columns) & set(df2.columns)
print(common_columns)

Output: {'B', 'C'}

This snippet first converts the column indices of both DataFrames to sets. Then it performs an intersection operation using the & operator, which identifies the common elements (columns) in both sets. The result is printed out, displaying the column names shared by both DataFrames.

Method 2: Using DataFrame attributes and the intersection() method

The Index object in Pandas has a built-in method called intersection() that can be used to find common elements. The columns of a DataFrame are represented by an Index object, which makes intersection() directly applicable for our task.

Here’s an example:

# Using the same sample DataFrames as before
common_columns = df1.columns.intersection(df2.columns)
print(common_columns)

Output: Index(['B', 'C'], dtype='object')

The code uses the intersection() method on the columns of the first DataFrame, passing the columns of the second DataFrame as an argument. The resultant Index object contains only the common columns, which are displayed in the output.

Method 3: Using List Comprehension

A Pythonic way to achieve the same result is through list comprehension, which can be a concise and readable method to filter elements in a list or array. By iterating over one DataFrame’s columns and checking if they’re in the second DataFrame’s columns, we can construct a list of common columns.

Here’s an example:

common_columns = [col for col in df1.columns if col in df2.columns]
print(common_columns)

Output: ['B', 'C']

The list comprehension checks for each column name in df1.columns if it is also present in df2.columns. Matching column names will be included in the common_columns list. This method offers a clear and straightforward approach for identifying common columns.

Method 4: Using the filter() function with a lambda

The filter() function in Python can be combined with a lambda function to filter out the common columns. This functional programming technique is useful for cases where a list comprehension may seem less expressive or when you wish to filter items based on some condition.

Here’s an example:

common_columns = list(filter(lambda col: col in df2.columns, df1.columns))
print(common_columns)

Output: ['B', 'C']

The filter() function applies a lambda that returns True for columns of df1 that are also in df2. Only the column names satisfying this condition are included in the resulting list, which is then printed.

Bonus One-Liner Method 5: Using Logical AND with in operator

A one-liner approach is to perform a logical AND operation with the in operator to extract the common columns. This is similar to the list comprehension method but more condensed and without the explicit iteration.

Here’s an example:

common_columns = list(set(df1.columns) & (col for col in df2.columns))
print(common_columns)

Output: ['B', 'C']

This approach applies logical AND using set intersection on a generator expression, which is lazily evaluated. It combines the explicit set conversion with the implicit generator that generates elements from df2.columns, resulting in a compact but clear one-liner.

Summary/Discussion

  • Method 1: Using Sets and the & operator. It is very intuitive and fast, especially for large lists. However, it returns a set instead of a list, which might not be desirable in all cases.
  • Method 2: DataFrame attributes and intersection(). This method is very readable and uses Pandas’ built-in Index object’s capabilities. The tradeoff is that it requires familiarity with DataFrame attributes and methods.
  • Method 3: List Comprehension. It’s clear and explicit, and many Python programmers are comfortable with this approach. However, it might not be as efficient as set operations for very large DataFrames.
  • Method 4: Using the filter() function with lambda. This functional approach is elegant but can be less intuitive to those not familiar with lambda or filter() functions.
  • Bonus Method 5: One-liner with Logical AND. It’s concise and gets the job done with minimal code. However, it mixes explicit set cast with generator expressions, which could be a bit perplexing to someone reading the code for the first time.